Showing posts with label Politico. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politico. Show all posts

Friday, May 20, 2011

Thank you, Jennifer Epstein

It appears that Politico has taken note of Andy Barr's unprofessional behavior and has decided to reassign at least a part of their Palin coverage to Jennifer Epstein.

Her article, analyzing Palin's appearance on Greta Van Susteren, is a first-rate example of honest and ethical journalism. Note that, although it is a short article like Barr's, Epstein uses multi-sentence paragraphs. She gets to the heart of the matter quickly, accurately conveying Palin's decision-making process regarding the one question everybody is asking right now - will she run?

Like Barr's article, Epstein's contains several Palin quotes. But instead of selectively inserting quotation marks in order to take Palin out of context, she chooses quotes that address the topic at hand. Beyond that, Epstein resists the urge to editorialize, instead simply and accurately summarizing Palin's answer to the question:
In an interview with Fox News’s Greta Van Susteren on Thursday night, the former Alaska governor said she has the inner drive to run, though she hasn’t decided whether to launch a campaign.
That right there, my friends, is the difference between partisan hackery and honest reporting. Andy Barr could learn a thing or two.

Tuesday, May 10, 2011

Andy Barr: Hack Journalism 101 (Part 1)

I'm sitting at Whole Foods listening to some good music on a warm spring day. (I know, but there just aren't many blogger-friendly establishments with free WiFi that don't attract liberals. Besides, they are a whole lot more capitalist than they let on.) Palin has come and gone, leaving in her wake mostly honest press coverage (for once), with one glaring exception: this horribly flawed article by Politico's Andy Barr. Frankly, I'm surprised that Politico hasn't bothered to print retractions. If I were a reputable news agency, I would insist that my reporters get the basic facts of their stories straight. I'm surprised no one has called for Andy Barr's resignation in this latest episode of media malpractice. Not only did Barr completely embarrass himself with this excuse for reporting, but he dug the hole even further on May 10th with another disingenuous article about Palin's poll numbers. Since the list of Barr's transgressions here is already pretty long, we'll deconstruct the second article in Part 2. In this episode, we take you deep inside the dark heart of hack journalism by wading through the demented inner working of Andy Barr's "brain", or whatever organ it is that resides inside his skull. Look at that Andy, I can use quotes to mock someone too!

The article starts out with an innocuous enough title: "Sarah Palin's pragmatic moment". But apparently, Barr has interpreted Palin's new-found pragmatism as a call to redouble his efforts to destroy her career. The article gradually deteriorates as you read further. Virtually every sentence is riddled with problems, so let's deconstruct them one by one:
Sarah Palin outlined a more detailed foreign policy agenda Monday night than she had before, arguing the mission that killed Osama bin Laden perfectly exemplifies a proper use of American force.
Why not just say that Palin outlined a concrete policy? According to lamestream media doctrine, Palin is never allowed to get anything right on foreign policy, so it was only "more detailed than before". Moreover, Palin did not merely "argue" that the mission exemplified a proper use of American force, she won the argument. Unless, of course, Barr would like to disagree with the President, the Democrats, the GOP, and virtually every American other than a few loons on the left who somehow think that taking out bin Laden equates to a violation of the chimerical construct of "international law". Heavens! The delicate sensibilities of terrorist sympathizing Pakistani officials might be offended that we did not first seek their approval before going after bin Laden (at which time, of course, bin Laden would have mysteriously disappeared). No Andy, Palin articulated a more solid foreign policy than I have heard from any other potential presidential candidate, including Obama, and knocked it out of the park.

Next sentence: